Upper Crust Pizza logo

"We have the largest selection of craft beers in the Upper Keys!"

Subs and Salads
Shrimp salad
Sub

A full dining experience

Come in and find a full selection of the area’s best salads, subs, and dinners. You will engage in an amazing dining experience that you will want to tell everyone about. We're more than just pizza! Explore our menu and find something delicious.

House salad

Don't forget to try one of our fresh, delicious homemade salads!

UPPER CRUST PIZZA

SALADS

All salads are served with House Italian dressing. $0.50 each extra

for blue cheese, honey mustard, thousand island, balsamic vinegar, ranch, or creamy Italian dressing

add $0.75 for small

add $1.50 for large


• croutons add $1.00

• extra dressing $0.75  each

served without onions


HOUSE SALAD

• small $6.95

• large $10.50

CHICKEN SALAD

* cheese and assortment of fresh veggie

$16.95
ANTIPASTA

* salami, ham, pepperoni, pepperoncini,  mozzarella cheese, and lots of veggies

$15.95
CAPRESE SALAD

* with fresh buffalo mozzarella, tomato, and fresh basil

$14.95
CHEESE SALAD

* Swiss, American, and mozzarella cheeses with avocado, mushroom, artichoke hearts, and fresh veggies

$14.95
CHEF SALAD

* ham, turkey, Swiss, and American cheeses with lots of fresh veggies

$15.95
SHRIMP SALAD

* fresh veggies and mozzarella cheese

• for blackened shrimp add $2.00

$19.95
Meatball sandwich
House salad

A wide variety of sub sandwiches to choose from.

UPPER CRUST PIZZA

SUBS

All subs served hot on our fresh homemade buns

add a side of fries for $3.00

sweet potato fries for $3.50

served without onions

GONDOLA

* ham, salami, mozzarella, lettuce, and herb oil

$11.99
TURKEY SUB

* lettuce, tomato, mayo, and mozzarella cheese

$11.99
VEGGIE SUB 1

* lettuce, tomato, mayo, herb oil, broccoli, cauliflower, and carrot topped with Swiss, American, and mozzarella cheese 

$10.99
EGGPLANT SUB

* with tomato sauce and cheese

$11.99
MEATBALL SUB

* with sauce and cheese

$13.99
BBQ CHICKEN SUB

* chicken, BBQ sauce, lettuce, American

cheese, and mayo

$14.99
CHICKEN FINGER SUB

* lettuce, tomato, honey mustard, and chicken fingers


$14.99
HAWAIIAN SUB

* bbq chicken, pineapple, and Swiss cheese 

$13.99
SLOPPY JOE SUB

 * with homemade meat sauce, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese

$14.99
HOAGIE

* ham, salami, American, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, and mayo

$11.99
CAPRESE SUB

* tomato, buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and herb oil

$14.99
VEGGIE SUB 2

* lettuce, tomato, mayo, herb oil, avocado, mushrooms, and black olives  topped with Swiss, American, and mozzarella cheese


$10.99
STEAK SUB

* onion, mushroom, and cheese

$13.99
SAUSAGE SUB

* grilled mushrooms, green peppers, tomato sauce, and cheese

$13.99
CHICKEN PARMIGIANO SUB

* with tomato sauce and cheese


$14.99
CHICKEN TERIYAKI SUB

* chicken, teriyaki sauce, lettuce, 

tomato, mayo, and mozzarella cheese

$13.99
CHICKEN PESTO SUB

* chicken with pesto sauce

$13.99

WHOLE WHEAT SANDWICHES

Served on our fresh, homemade whole wheat bread

add a side of fries for $3.00

sweet potato fries for $3.50

TURKEY MELT

* turkey, mayo, tomato, and mozzarella cheese

$10.95
VEGGIE MELT

* mushroom, veggie mix, mayo, Swiss, and mozzarella cheese


$10.95
Click here to download Full Menu

Ask about our Tuesday and Thursday specials as well as our Monday through Friday lunch specials!

Salad

We also offer delivery and takeout options. A minimum order of $15 is required for delivery. Call us today to place your order!

Share by: