Upper Crust Pizza logo

"We have the largest selection of craft beers in the Upper Keys!"

Drinks and Desserts
Tasty cake
Draft beer

Refreshing drinks and delectable desserts

Come on in and try our homemade sangria with fresh fruit or grab a beer with friends. More interested in dessert? We have homemade key lime pie, ice cream, or tiramisu that will finish off any meal the right way.

Sangria

Wine, beer, homemade sangria, and more! Why go anywhere else!

crustbeer

UPPER CRUST PIZZA

SOFT DRINKS

FOUNTAIN

* Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Sierra Mist, Root Beer, Club Soda, and Lemonade

$3.95
CANS

* Coke, Diet Coke, Sunkist, and Mountain Dew

$2.75
COFFEE

• cappuccino $5.25

• espresso $4.25

$3.75
ICED TEA

* fresh brewed iced tea

$3.50
MILK

• chocolate milk $5.50

$4.50
MILKSHAKE

• vanilla • chocolate • strawberry

$8.95
JUICE

* orange juice or apple juice

$6.50
BOTTLED WATER
$2.95
pie

Finish off your meal with a delicious dessert!

UPPER CRUST PIZZA

DESSERTS

HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE

• slice $6.95

• whole pie $20.95

HOMEMADE TIRAMISU

* slice $8.95

ICE CREAM

* vanilla, strawberry, or chocolate dish

$6.95
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
$1.50

A 22% gratuity will be added automatically for parties of 6 or more. Prices are subject to change without notice.

Click here to download Full Menu

Ask about our Tuesday and Thursday specials as well as our Monday through Friday lunch specials!

tiramisu

Whether you are just stopping by for a few drinks with friends or want the entire family to enjoy a night out, we are here to serve you.

Share by: