"We have the largest selection of craft beers in the Upper Keys!"

Upper Crust Pizza
Salads subs

A full dining experience

Come in and find a full selection of the area’s best salads, subs, and dinners. You will engage in an amazing dining experience that you will want to tell everyone about. We're more than just pizza! Explore our menu and find something delicious.

Ask about our

Tuesday and Thursday specials

as well as our

Monday through Friday lunch specials!

We also offer delivery and takeout options. A minimum order of $15 is required for delivery. Call us today to place your order!





Don't forget to try one of our fresh, delicious homemade salads!

House salad


subs-salad-support3-340-365 Shrimp salad

A wide variety of sub sandwiches to choose from.

House salad 5154818 Click here to view full menu Click here to view full menu

House Salad                                              

$4.95 (sm)

$8.50 (lg)

Cheese Salad  


Swiss, American, and Mozzarella Cheeses

with Avocado, Mushroom, Artichoke Hearts

and Fresh Veggies

Chicken Salad  


Cheese and an assortment of fresh veggies

For blackened chicken add $3.00

Tuna Salad  


Chef's Salad


Ham, Turkey, Swiss and American cheeses

with lots of fresh veggies



Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, Peperoncini

Mozzarella cheese and lots of veggies

Shirmp Salad


Fresh Veggies, Mozzarella Cheese,

Blackened Shrimp add $2.00

Gondola (Italian Mix)


Ham, Salami, Mozzarella, Lettuce

and Herb Oil

Hoagie (American Mix)


Ham, Salami, American, Swiss,

Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo

Turkey Sub


Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo and

Mozzarella Cheese

Cold Tuna Sub


Tuna Salad, American Cheese,

Lettuce, Tomato

Meatball Sub


with Sauce and Cheese

Steak Sub


Sauteed Onion, Mushrooms, Cheese

Sausage Sub


Grilled Mushrooms, Green Peppers,

Tomato Sauce and Cheese

Chicken Parmesan Sub


with Tomato Sauce and Cheese

BBQ Chicken Sub  


Chicken, BBQ Sauce, Lettuce,

American Cheese and Mayo

Chicken Teriyaki Sub  


Chicken, Teriyaki Sauce, Lettuce,

Tomato, Mayo and Mozzarella Cheese

Blackened Chicken Sub


Blackened Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato,

Mayo and Mozzarella Cheese    

Chicken Finger Sub


Lettuce, Tomato, Honey Mustard,

Chicken Fingers

Hawaiian Sub


BBQ Chicken, Pineapple and Swiss


Eggplant Sub


Tomato Sauce and Cheese

Veggie Sub 1      


Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Herb Oil,

Broccoli, Cauliflower and Carrot,

topped with Swiss, American and

Mozzarella Cheese

Veggie Sub 2      


Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Herb Oil,

Avocado, Mushrooms, Black Olives,

topped with Swiss, American and

Mozarella Cheese